IBM continues to confound and amaze


Author: Barry Randall, Crabtree Asset Management

Covestor model: Crabtree Technology

January 2012 was a strong month not only for the Crabtree Technology model, but also for the capital markets as a whole. A steady stream of solid economic news, such as three-year lows in the weekly U. S. unemployment claims, bolstered confidence in general and investor confidence in particular.

In the world of technology, however, there were hits and misses, particularly when it came to reporting December quarter earnings. There were very solid reports from Apple, IBM and Netflix. Conversely, Google and Amazon disappointed, causing each company’s stock to decline sharply the day after each reported numbers.

Among Crabtree holdings, IBM (IBM), Electronics for Imaging (EFII) and OSI Systems (OSIS) were the standouts, in each case exceeding expectations and offering forward outlooks ahead of expectations – either their own prior outlook, or Wall Street estimates.

Disappointments came from Symantec (SYMC) and Electro Scientific Industries (ESIO), though neither of those two companies’ quarters would be considered to be “blow-ups” in Wall Street parlance.

Nonetheless, February will bring with it a rebalancing of the Crabtree Fund, and those companies failing to exhibit the key Crabtree characteristics (e.g. execution on their business model) will be swapped out for those still possessing them. Of course, earnings season for the December quarter won’t be over until mid-February, so we’ll have more to say in next month’s report, plus an update on the fund’s composition, which will have changed by then.

Because we don’t really “react”  to the general economic and financial news flow by selling current holdings or buying new ones, we typically don’t pay too much attention to the daily headlines. However, we do have strong feelings about certain companies. Here are a few words about this month’s featured Crabtree holding, IBM.

IBM continues to confound and amaze people. The most recent surprise was when notoriously tech-averse billionaire Warren Buffett took a large position (is there any other kind of Buffett position?). But we think that Mr. Buffett simply came to understand what we have known for many years: IBM doesn’t manufacture business machines. They manufacture earnings. They do so as follows (source – IBM reports and Yahoo Finance):

  1. IBM runs a very profitable technology services business ($40.9 billion in 2011 revenue; 35% gross margins), and charges their service clients for the computer hardware and software they install, generating…
  2. …prodigious cash flow (18.5% operating cash flow margins) with which they…
  3. …buy back stock (paid $15 billion in 2011) and …
  4. …acquire more high-profit margin software companies (spent $1.8B in 2011) whose products they sell…
  5. …through their very profitable technology services business, repeating this cycle over and over.

To put some more numbers to this amazing machine, consider that at the end of 2011, IBM had 1.189 billion shares outstanding, down from 1.605 billion shares at the end of 2005. That’s an astounding 26% decline in the share base, or a 35% boost to earnings per share, absent any other effect.

IBM hasn’t really amazed us at Crabtree. We cottoned to their secret strategy years ago. It is an example of why we generally pay no attention whatsoever to a “tech”  company’s technology and focus almost exclusively on a company’s business model and market opportunity. Sure, IBM created Watson, their Jeopardy-winning supercomputer, but it is the aforementioned acquisition/cash flow/buy-back cycle that keeps us as investors. IBM has been a holding in the Crabtree Fund since we started it nearly three years ago. Welcome aboard Warren!

Well, that’s all for this month. February will bring many more earnings reports. Plus, Facebook just filed for an IPO yesterday, so we’ll be digging into their SEC filings. We’ll have completed our quarterly re-balancing of the Crabtree Fund by the end of February, so we’ll let you know about what’s new in the portfolio.  See you then!

Author profile

Barry Randall
Barry Randall
Crabtree Asset Management invests in growing technology companies. Barry Randall is the firm's founder and chief investment officer. He has more than 20 years of professional investing experience.

Barry spent five years as a technology stock analyst and 10 more years managing mutual funds that focused on small-cap and technology stocks. He has experience managing mutual funds and separately managed accounts as large as $650 million. Prior to earning his MBA in 1993, he spent six years as a professional computer programmer.

Barry earned a Wall Street Journal 'Category King' award for his co-management of a small cap mutual fund in 2006.

As of December 2016, Morningstar rated the Crabtree Multi-Cap Technology composite, of which the strategy offered at Covestor is a component, as having four stars (out of five) for its overall and trailing 5-year performance.

Barry has been quoted regularly in Forbes, US News & World Report, TheStreet.com and E-Commerce Times. He has appeared on CNBC, Bloomberg TV and Fox Business News.

Crabtree Asset Management LLC was founded in 2008 and is headquartered in Saint Paul, Minnesota.